Desserts Made with Homemade Tradition

Not quite a cookie, not quite a pie — this is the sweet spot in between. Our desserts category brings together a variety of homemade-style baked goods that don’t fit the usual mold, but are every bit as delicious. Enjoy gooey brownies, sticky-sweet cinnamon rolls, and moist, flavorful loaves like banana nut and cinnamon apple from Kauffman’s Bakery. You’ll also find classic buckeyes from Village Bakery, the perfect balance of rich peanut butter and chocolate. Whether you’re picking up a treat for yourself or something to share, these baked desserts deliver the homemade comfort and quality you expect from Troyer’s Dutch Market.