Cookies Made the Old-Fashioned Way

There’s nothing quite like the taste of a homemade cookie — soft, sweet, and baked with love. At Troyer’s Dutch Market, we offer a wide selection of homemade cookies made from time-honored Amish and Dutch Country recipes. You’ll find favorites from trusted names like Troyer’s Home Pantry, Village Bakery, and Kauffman’s Bakery, each bringing their own unique flavor and tradition to the table. From chewy chocolate chip to oatmeal raisin, iced cutouts, and more, every cookie is made with quality ingredients and baked to perfection. Whether you’re stocking up for gatherings or grabbing a sweet treat for yourself, our cookies bring a little homemade joy to every bite.