Skip to content
Shop
Deli Meats and Cheeses
Deli Meats
Deli Cheeses
Baked Goods & Desserts
Our local baked goods and desserts are crafted with love and care, reflecting the rich traditions and flavors of Ohio’s Amish Country. From freshly baked breads and rolls to mouth-watering pies and cookies, every treat is made with the best ingredients and a touch of homegrown charm that you won’t find anywhere else. So come and explore the mouth-watering treats that await you. All items are available for pre-order. In-store availability may vary. Call ahead to check availability or place your order today — and don’t forget to ask about curbside pick-up!
Breads
Desserts
Frozen Products
Cookies
Pies
Dedicated to old-fashioned great taste, Troyer’s Home Pantry Pies are sure to impress anyone you serve a slice to. Freshly baked in Apple Creek, Ohio and offered in both 6-inch and 9-inch sizes, these pies come in a variety of different flavors, appealing to even the pickiest of eaters.
Troyer’s Home Pantry Pies
Dedicated to old-fashioned great taste, Troyer’s Home Pantry Pies are sure to impress anyone you serve a slice to. Freshly baked in Apple Creek, Ohio and offered in both 6-inch and 9-inch sizes, these pies come in a variety of different flavors, appealing to even the pickiest of eaters.
6-inch Pies
9-inch Pies
Troyer’s Meat, Cheese and Party Trays
Café Menu
Subs
Wraps
Salads
Resources
About Troyer’s Dutch Market
Contact Troyer’s Dutch Market
Troyer’s Dutch Market Brands
Troyer’s Frequently Asked Questions
Troyer’s News and Notices
Weekly Deli Specials
Search
×
Search for:
all-year
Showing 1–20 of 28 results
Default sorting
Sort by popularity
Sort by average rating
Sort by latest
Sort by price: low to high
Sort by price: high to low
Read more
9″ Apple
Read more
9″ Banana Cream
Read more
9″ Blackberry
Read more
9″ Blueberry
Read more
9″ Blueberry Cheesecake
Read more
9″ Blueberry Cream
Read more
9″ Cheesecake
Read more
9″ Cherry
Read more
9″ Cherry Cheesecake
Read more
9″ Cherry Crumb
Read more
9″ Chocolate Cream
Read more
9″ Coconut Cream
Read more
9″ Custard
Read more
9″ Dutch Apple
Read more
9″ Elderberry
Read more
9″ Lemon Cheesecake
Read more
9″ Lemon Meringue
Read more
9″ Peach
Read more
9″ Peanut Butter Chocolate Cream
Read more
9″ Peanut Butter Cream
Posts navigation
1
2
Next page
Check Out Our Menu
Deli Meats & Cheeses
Trays
Baked Goods & Desserts
Pies
Subs
Wraps
Salads
View Cafe Menu
Scroll to Top
Call Now Button
Skip to content
Open toolbar
Accessibility Tools
Accessibility Tools
Increase Text
Increase Text
Decrease Text
Decrease Text
Grayscale
Grayscale
High Contrast
High Contrast
Negative Contrast
Negative Contrast
Light Background
Light Background
Links Underline
Links Underline
Readable Font
Readable Font
Reset
Reset
