Troyer's Café Menu
Welcome to the café menu at Troyer’s Dutch Market, where fresh, made-to-order deli subs, wraps, and salads are prepared daily. We use high-quality ingredients, including trusted deli meats and cheeses from Walnut Creek Foods, so every bite delivers bold, satisfying flavor.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, meeting a friend, or picking up something fresh and filling for the day, our café menu features classic deli favorites and lighter options that still hit the spot. Take a look and find your next go-to meal.
The café closes at 4:45pm Tuesday through Friday and 3:15pm on Saturday
The deli closes at
4:45pm Tuesday through Friday
and 3:15pm on Saturday
All Subs $6.99
Extra Meat $1.00
Extra Cheese $1.00
Our café subs come on fresh-baked 6-7 inch Village Bakery sub buns, Choose from any of the options below—or build your own!
Made to order and packed with flavor.
Toppings:
Ketchup, Mustard, Mayo, Horseradish Sauce
Dressing:
All Wraps $6.99
Extra Meat $1.00
Extra Cheese $1.00
Our café wraps are made fresh with your choice of Walnut Creek flour or spinach tortilla wraps.
Choose from any of the options below—or build your own! Made fresh to order and perfect for lunch, dinner, or anything in between.
Toppings:
Ketchup, Mustard, Mayo, Horseradish Sauce
Dressing:
Download Our Café and Pie Menu
Step into the heart of Amish Country and experience the warmth and charm of our café menu. From savory meats and delicious cheeses to a medley of fresh produce, our subs, wraps, and salads are a true celebration of the bountiful nature that surrounds Ohio’s Amish Country.
